I was given this one, and while it's pretty good, I don't think I would've bought it. The only thing I've been buying tie-in merchandise for lately is SGA (because I am just that pathetic) but I agree, fanfic is usually better than tie-ins with almost every fandom (and SGA is no exception to that). I think at least part of that is because you can "shop around" with fanfic to find the right kinks (i.e. h/c, in my case).