2009-12-26

xparrot: Chopper reading (Default)
2009-12-26 05:41 pm
Entry tags:

regarding Sherlock Holmes

The Holmes movie inspired me to go rereading certain key scenes (my collected edition is still packed away, so I've been trawling this site for links). There's a lot of little details in the movie that are from the canon but I'd forgotten them (Watson mentioning owning a bull pup in the first novel, and such.) RDJ's Holmes doesn't quite look the part, but his manic brilliance is perfect. And Jude Law's Watson is maybe a bit snarkier than the original, but I love him that way. Really the movie's total fanfic - good fanfic, taking the best bits of canon and running wild with them.

And, lest anyone regard the movie as excessively slashy, may I note for the record the canon's subtext. For example, take all these lines from a single story ("The Final Problem", possibly the original cliff-hanger?)

quotes to follow - spoilers, I guess? albeit for a story more than a century old... )

...I swear that I once came across an online compilation of all the slashy quotes in the Holmes canon, but have had no luck finding it...